Evidence & Policy Watch — 22 September 2026

Issue of 22 September 2026 · Next issue 29 September 2026

Issues

5

Reviewer’s picks

25

New articles across 14 journals

2

New reports and evaluations

12

Bills tracked

This week’s contrast

Domestic and family violence: the bill and the emergency-department evidence

Evidence

Emergency Department Implementation of Care Models for Individuals Experiencing Family and Domestic Violence and Abuse: A Systematic Scoping Review

Hicks et al. · Trauma, Violence, & Abuse · 5 September 2026 · Open access

A scoping review of 25 peer-reviewed studies (1995–2025, screened from 1,529 records) describing how hospital emergency departments implement models of care for people experiencing family and domestic violence, mapped to Normalisation Process Theory. Eleven studies described implementation of at least two components of comprehensive care and seven addressed all four (referral in, context of care, care delivered, referral out). Recurring features were a dedicated family violence practitioner, models developed within the department itself, and closed-loop communication with staff. The authors note that direct evaluations of comprehensive models and of their implementation remain limited.

Legislation

Domestic and Family Violence Protection and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2026

Queensland Parliament · introduced 17 September 2026

Amends the Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012 and, through Schedule 1, the Bail Act 1980, the Criminal Code, the Evidence Act 1977, the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000, the Weapons Act 1990 and the Victims’ Commissioner and Sexual Violence Review Board Act 2024, among others. As introduced, the bill restructures police protection directions: it removes the provisions that limited when an officer may issue one and the police review procedure, sets out cool-down, no-contact, ouster, return and recovery conditions, permits cross-directions only in exceptional circumstances, extends a direction’s duration from 12 months to 3 years, and provides for directions to be filed with a court as applications for protection orders. It requires courts to consider a monitoring device condition when making a domestic violence order and to give reasons if none is imposed, and removes the police protection notice provisions. The Schedule 1 amendments were not retrievable in full; the Minister’s statement of 17 September 2026 describes them as including new offences for repeated contraventions of directions and orders. Commencement is by proclamation.

Read together: the bill changes what police can do at the point of first contact with a domestic violence incident — the conditions they can impose, how long a direction lasts, and how it reaches a court — and asks courts to consider electronic monitoring. The review looks at a different point of first contact, the hospital emergency department, and at what the published studies say sustains a comprehensive response once one is introduced. This page places the two side by side. It does not take a position on either.

Earlier evidence related to this policy

Protection orders and police-issued notices in domestic violence: what earlier studies found

Older studies on the kind of intervention the legislation provides for. Each tile summarises one study descriptively; dates are the original publication dates.

Cohort study · 2002

Civil Protection Orders and Risk of Subsequent Police-Reported Violence

Holt et al. · JAMA · 2002

What the study found

A retrospective cohort study of 2,691 adult women in Seattle with an incident of male intimate partner violence reported to police between August 1998 and December 1999, comparing police-reported abuse in the following 12 months by protection order status (temporary order, usually two weeks; permanent order, usually 12 months; no order). After controlling for cohabitation and index offence type, women with temporary orders were more likely than women without orders to experience police-reported psychological abuse (relative risk 4.9 over 12 months), while women with permanent orders were less likely to experience police-reported physical abuse (relative risk 0.2 over 12 months). The authors conclude that permanent, but not temporary, protection orders were associated with a significant decrease in police-reported violence.

Read the study →

Systematic review · 2018

Protection orders for domestic violence: A systematic review

Dowling, Morgan, Hulme, Manning and Wong · Australian Institute of Criminology, Trends & issues no. 551 · June 2018

What the study found

An Australian Institute of Criminology systematic review of research on the use and impact of domestic violence protection orders, using the EMMIE framework (effectiveness, mechanisms, moderators, implementation and economy), with meta-analysis for the overall effect and narrative synthesis for the rest. The review reports that protection orders are associated with a small but significant reduction in domestic violence, that they appear more effective where the victim has fewer ties to the perpetrator and greater capacity for independence, and less effective for perpetrators with histories of crime, violence and mental health problems.

Read the study →

Meta-analysis · 2021

The Effectiveness of Protection Orders in Reducing Recidivism in Domestic Violence: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Cordier, Chung, Wilkes-Gillan and Speyer · Trauma, Violence, & Abuse · 2021 (online 2019)

What the study found

A systematic review and meta-analysis of 25 studies evaluating the effectiveness of civil protection orders in reducing domestic violence, comparing violation rates from victim reports and police reports and identifying factors associated with violation. Violation rates were higher in victim reports than in police records; violation rates were lower when orders were used in combination with arrest, among perpetrators without a history of arrest for violence, where the perpetrator was not stalking, and among couples with medium to high incomes. The authors note no consensus on how effectiveness should be measured and call for a more unified evaluation approach.

Read the study →

Pilot evaluation · 2013

Evaluation of the pilot of Domestic Violence Protection Orders

Kelly et al. · Home Office Research Report 76 · November 2013

What the study found

The Home Office evaluation of the 2011–12 pilot of Domestic Violence Protection Notices and Orders in three police force areas of England and Wales: police-issued notices followed by short court orders that can remove a perpetrator from the home where other remedies are not immediately available. The evaluation reports that practitioners and victim-survivors generally viewed the orders favourably, that the available evidence suggested a reduction in repeat victimisation compared with arrest followed by no further action, with the clearest difference in longer-term abuse, and that the measured costs exceeded measured benefits within the pilot period; it recommended wider roll-out.

Read the study →

Police data study · 2020

A critical reflection on the use and effectiveness of DVPNs and DVPOs

Blackburn and Graca · Police Practice and Research · 2020

What the study found

An empirical ‘snapshot’ of the use of Domestic Violence Protection Notices and Orders by London’s Metropolitan Police Service, set against the legal context in which the orders were created (risk management, human rights and violence against women) and the policies used to deploy them. The article considers whether the orders can be regarded as achieving their intended short-term protective outcomes, and discusses the implications of their replacement by Domestic Abuse Protection Notices and Orders under the then Domestic Abuse Bill.

Read the study →

Evidence Watch

New research, selected for relevance to Australian justice agencies and services

5 reviewer’s picks from this fortnight’s publications. Open a tile for the summary and a link to the article.

Risk assessment

Criminal history’s expiration date: Evidence of prediction decay

Hamilton et al. · Criminology · 19 September 2026 · Open access

Summary and relevance

Uses a five-state population of criminal charges spanning 40 years (16.6 million people; 746 million person-year observations) to model, charge by charge, how the predictive value of a prior offence declines with each year that passes. Recidivism risk followed an exponential decay pattern that held across locations, demographic groups, offence types, incarceration exposure and historical period, and converged with the population base rate within 9 to 10 years. Relevant to Australian corrections and courts that use criminal history in risk assessment, and to criminal-record and spent-conviction schemes.

Read the article →

Sexual violence

Police Documentation of Complainant Truthfulness Concerns in Sexual Assault: A Mixed Methods Examination of Case Files

Meeker et al. · Crime & Delinquency · 20 September 2026 · Open access

Summary and relevance

A mixed-methods study of police sexual assault case files examining which factors are associated with officers recording concerns about a complainant’s truthfulness. Complainant character issues, inconsistent accounts, recantation and assessments of credibility were associated with documented concerns, and the qualitative analysis describes the assumptions officers made when recording them. The abstract does not report the jurisdiction or the number of files examined. Relevant to police services and prosecution agencies reviewing sexual assault attrition and investigative practice.

Read the article →

Child protection

The Development and Validation of a Preliminary Model for Classifying Technology Facilitated Child Sexual Exploitation and Abuse by Men in the General Population

Whitten et al. · Sexual Abuse · 18 September 2026 · Open access

Summary and relevance

Develops and validates a 13-item model for classifying self-reported technology-facilitated child sexual exploitation and abuse among adult men, using census-weighted samples from Australia (n = 1,939), the United Kingdom (n = 1,506) and the United States (n = 1,473). Built with penalised regression and repeated cross-validation in the Australian sample, the model discriminated well (AUROC 0.91) and held up in the UK and US samples; decision-curve analysis indicated a net gain of 42 true positives per 1,000 Australian men assessed at the chosen threshold, with higher net benefit among men who work with children. Presented as proof-of-concept evidence; relevant to Australian child protection, online safety and child-safe organisation settings.

Read the article →

Image-based abuse

Sexualized Deepfake Abuse as Image-Based Sexual Abuse: A Scoping Review of Platform-Mediated Circulation and Cumulative Harm

Gao · Trauma, Violence, & Abuse · 15 September 2026

Summary and relevance

A scoping review of 54 peer-reviewed articles published between December 2017 and January 2026 on sexualised deepfake abuse, treated as a form of image-based sexual abuse. Legal and conceptual scholarship predominated, with comparatively little victim-centred empirical or intervention research; harm was traced across production, distribution, visibility and recirculation and described as cumulative, taking in distress, stigma, self-censorship and the procedural burden of seeking removal. The paper proposes a lifecycle model of harm and response and notes that direct evaluations of interventions remain scarce. Relevant to Australian agencies administering image-based abuse offences and to victim support services.

Read the article →

Youth justice

Friendship network integration and peer deviance: Revisiting the mechanisms connecting juvenile arrest with subsequent offending

Ragan & Jacobsen · Criminology · 3 September 2026 · Open access

Summary and relevance

Uses longitudinal data on more than 13,000 school students in grades 6 to 11 to test whether arrest is followed by weaker integration into school friendship networks and greater involvement with deviant peers, and whether those changes account for later offending. Arrest was associated with declining network integration and with greater peer deviance, both more pronounced for girls, but the study found little evidence that these changes in peer relationships explained subsequent increases in deviant behaviour. Relevant to youth justice agencies and schools considering the collateral effects of early justice contact.

Read the article →

Also published this month

25 new articles across the 14 journals tracked. Open a journal to see its items; titles link to the publisher record.

Criminology · 2 new
Criminology & Public Policy · 2 new
Journal of Criminal Justice (in press) · 2 new
Journal of Experimental Criminology · 2 new
Journal of Quantitative Criminology · 2 new
Journal of Developmental and Life-Course Criminology · 2 new
Justice Quarterly · 2 new
Crime & Delinquency · 2 new
British Journal of Criminology · 2 new
Criminal Justice and Behavior · 2 new
Sexual Abuse · 1 new
Journal of Sexual Aggression · 2 new
Trauma, Violence, & Abuse · 2 new
Campbell Systematic Reviews · none this period

No new items recorded in this period.

New reports and evaluations

Government and research-body releases

Reports, evaluations and statistical releases from Australian justice and research bodies. Each tile links to the source.

Policy & Legislation Watch

Bills, inquiries and law-reform activity in Queensland and the Commonwealth

Open a tile for what the bill does and which Acts it amends. Status is stated as dated facts only.

Queensland bills

Queensland bill

Domestic and Family Violence Protection and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2026

Introduced 17 September 2026

What the bill does

Amends the Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012 and, through Schedule 1, the Bail Act 1980, the Criminal Code, the Evidence Act 1977, the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000, the Weapons Act 1990 and the Victims’ Commissioner and Sexual Violence Review Board Act 2024, among others. As introduced, the bill restructures police protection directions (removing the limits on when one may be issued and the police review procedure; setting out cool-down, no-contact, ouster, return and recovery conditions; permitting cross-directions only in exceptional circumstances; extending duration from 12 months to 3 years; and providing for a direction to be filed with a court as an application for a protection order), requires courts to consider a monitoring device condition when making a domestic violence order and to give reasons if none is imposed, requires a court hearing an existing application to consider safety and wellbeing arrangements for vulnerable persons, and removes the police protection notice provisions. Commencement is by proclamation. See this week’s contrast above.

Read the bill →

Queensland bill

Justice Legislation (Strengthening Victims’ Rights) Amendment Bill 2026

Introduced 16 September 2026

What the bill does

Amends the Coroners Act 2003, the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 and, through Schedule 1, the Evidence Act 1977, the Victims’ Commissioner and Sexual Violence Review Board Act 2024 and the Youth Justice Act 1992. As introduced, the bill requires the Coroners Court to notify family members of decisions to hold, reopen or resume an inquest; widens the sentencing provisions on victim impact statements to domestic violence offences and indictable offences generally, defines ‘victim’ to include affected family members, allows another person to prepare a statement with the court’s approval, allows a court to receive a statement containing otherwise inadmissible material while disregarding that material, and provides for audio-visual recording of statements read in court; restricts cross-examination of victims on their statements; and establishes community impact statements prepared by the Victims’ Commissioner for terrorism and specified violent offences. The Coroners Act amendments commence 7 days after assent; the remainder by proclamation.

Read the bill →

Queensland bill

Victims of Crime Assistance (Victims’ Advocate Service) Amendment Bill 2026

Introduced 16 September 2026

What the bill does

Amends the Victims of Crime Assistance Act 2009 to insert a new Chapter 3A establishing a victims’ advocate service. The chief executive’s functions are to support victims, and eligible persons acting for them, to access information held by government entities and to access victim services, by requesting information on a victim’s authorisation, referring people to services and providing general information about services and the administration of criminal justice; the chief executive may not make, sign or submit an application on a victim’s behalf, may not pay a fee, and may not use the Right to Information Act 2009 or Information Privacy Act 2009. A government entity may give the requested information despite other confidentiality laws where satisfied the victim is entitled to it. The chapter applies irrespective of when the harm occurred. Commencement is 8 December 2026.

Read the bill →

Queensland bill

Protecting Queenslanders from Dangerous Prisoners and Strengthening Victims’ Rights Amendment Bill 2026

Introduced 15 September 2026

What the bill does

Amends the Corrective Services Act 2006, the Victims’ Commissioner and Sexual Violence Review Board Act 2024 and the Youth Justice Act 1992. As introduced: mandatory and subsequent restricted-prisoner declarations for life-sentenced restricted prisoners (a mandatory declaration sets a 5 to 10 year period during which the prisoner cannot apply for parole; further declarations are discretionary); extends the ‘no body, no parole’ provisions to prisoners serving terms for homicide offences where the victim’s remains have not been located, applying a ‘timely and satisfactory cooperation’ test; requires notification of registered victims within 7 days of a parole application, allows 42 days for victim submissions and provides for victims, support persons and advocates to appear before the Parole Board; provides for electronic scanning of privileged mail; and declares that section 58 of the Human Rights Act 2019 does not apply to specified corrective services decisions, subject to a five-year sunset. Carried over from last issue; no committee report date verified.

Read the bill →

Queensland bill

Youth Justice (Circuit Breaker) Amendment Bill 2026

Introduced 25 June 2026 · Justice, Integrity and Community Safety Committee reported 14 August 2026 · passed 17 September 2026

What the bill does

Amends the Youth Justice Act 1992, the Child Safe Organisations Act 2024 and the Public Guardian Act 2014. Introduces circuit breaker conditions on bail and circuit breaker orders at sentencing for children, requiring participation in an intensive residential program delivered by an approved provider at a designated site, with electronic monitoring, and establishes the provider, oversight and coordination framework for those programs. The Minister’s statement of 17 September 2026 records the bill’s passage and says the program is expected to commence later in 2026; the passed text had not appeared on the legislation register when this issue was compiled.

Read the bill →

Queensland bill

Criminal Code (Dangerous Driving) and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2026

Introduced 26 June 2026 · referred to the State Development, Infrastructure and Works Committee · passed 17 September 2026

What the bill does

Amends the Criminal Code, the District Court of Queensland Act 1967, the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000, the Transport Operations (Passenger Transport) Act 1994, the Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act 1995 and the Youth Justice Act 1992. As introduced, the bill replaces the dangerous operation offence in section 328A with a new Chapter 29B containing four offences (driving a motor vehicle dangerously, interfering dangerously with the driving of a motor vehicle, and the equivalent offences for non-motor vehicles), with maximum penalties of 5 years’ imprisonment for the base motor-vehicle offences and 16 years where death or grievous bodily harm is caused, higher maxima where material advertising the conduct is published, minimum licence disqualification periods of 6 months to 5 years, and mandatory imprisonment for specified repeat offenders. Commencement is 1 March 2027. Passage is recorded in the Minister’s statement of 17 September 2026; the passed text had not appeared on the legislation register when this issue was compiled.

Read the bill →

Queensland bill

Breach Bail, Go to Jail and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2026

Introduced 27 August 2026 · under inquiry by the Justice, Integrity and Community Safety Committee · public hearing held 18 September 2026

What the bill does

Amends the Bail Act 1980, the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000, the Young Offenders (Interstate Transfer) Act 1987 and the Youth Justice Act 1992. As introduced, the bill applies a stricter bail test to defendants charged with prescribed offences allegedly committed while on bail, unlawfully at large or having failed to appear (the court must be satisfied to a high degree of confidence that no further prescribed offence will be committed); creates a new offence carrying a mandatory minimum of one year’s imprisonment for adults who commit prescribed offences, and children who commit significant offences, while on bail or unlawfully at large; expands the grounds for refusing release for children in similar circumstances and removes the mandatory consideration of alternatives to prosecution and arrest in particular contexts; and includes Human Rights Act 2019 override declarations that expire after five years.

Read the bill →

Queensland bill

Queensland Protection Commission Bill 2026

Introduced 26 August 2026

What the bill does

Establishes the Queensland Protection Commissioner, supported by a Queensland Protection Commission, to protect the safety and wellbeing of children, young people and other vulnerable persons and to provide oversight of the child protection system. Amends the Child Safe Organisations Act 2024, the Disability Services Act 2006 and the Working with Children Check Act 2000, among others. Carried over from last issue; no committee report date verified.

Read the bill →

Commonwealth bills

Commonwealth bill

Criminal Code Amendment (National Sport Integrity Offences) Bill 2026

Introduced 20 August 2026 · referred to the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee 20 August 2026 · committee report due 2 October 2026

What the bill does

Creates Commonwealth offences for match-fixing and related conduct that corrupts the outcome of sporting events, with maximum penalties of up to ten years’ imprisonment. The Attorney-General’s second reading speech refers to the Macolin Convention on the manipulation of sports competitions.

Read more →

Commonwealth bill

Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill 2026

Introduced in the House of Representatives 12 August 2026 · second reading agreed to 19 August 2026

What the bill does

Amends the Criminal Code Act 1995 and the Crimes Act 1914. Extends the sunset dates for control orders, preventative detention orders and post-sentence orders (Criminal Code divisions 104, 105 and 105A) and for the police powers in Division 3A of Part IAA of the Crimes Act for a further three years, to 7 December 2029; establishes control orders as the primary Commonwealth mechanism for managing terrorist offenders after sentence and removes the AFP Minister’s authority to apply for extended supervision orders; extends the maximum duration of a control order for a person aged 14 to 17 from 3 to 12 months; removes the public application process for de-listing terrorist organisations; and extends the Division 71 offences protecting United Nations personnel to additional types of UN operation (Parliamentary Library preliminary Bills Digest). No later stage was verifiable when this issue was compiled.

Read more →

Commonwealth bill

Crimes and Other Legislation Amendment (Omnibus No. 1) Bill 2026

Introduced 11 March 2026 · passed the House of Representatives 25 March 2026 · Senate second reading debate 11 August 2026

What the bill does

Amends eight Commonwealth crimes-related Acts to update and clarify the operation of key provisions, including extending sunset dates for surveillance warrants, replacing purity-based drug threshold calculations with a mixture-weight approach, and clarifying police powers of entry when executing extradition warrants (Parliamentary Library Bills Digest). No later stage was verifiable when this issue was compiled.

Read more →

Commonwealth bill

Crimes Amendment (Prohibiting the Strip Searching of Children) Bill 2026

Private senator’s bill · referred to the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee 20 August 2026 · committee report due 13 October 2026

What the bill does

A private senator’s bill to amend the Crimes Act 1914 to prohibit strip searches of people under 18 in police, prison and youth detention settings. Referred by the Senate on the report of the Selection of Bills Committee of 20 August 2026; introduction date not verified.

Read more →

Law reform

Law reform

Queensland Law Reform Commission — Evidence Law Review

Review launched 14 May 2026 · Background Paper 2 dated July 2026 · final report due to the Attorney-General by 1 December 2027

Where it stands

A review of the Evidence Act 1977 (Qld). Background Paper 2, ‘Evidence law by design’, sets out the Commission’s approach to drafting: it describes the growth and amendment history of the current Act and proposes applying legislative design principles (coherence, durability, comprehensibility and navigability) to a redrafted Act adapted to Queensland, drawing on the Uniform Evidence Law where relevant. The paper indicates that a consultation paper and draft exposure bill will follow; no dates are given.

Source →

Law reform

Queensland Law Reform Commission — Report on self-defence, provocation and other defences in the Criminal Code

Released 21 April 2026

Where it stands

The final report makes 36 recommendations, including a simplified self-defence test and repeal of the provocation defences. No Government response had been published on the Commission’s news page when this issue was compiled.

Source →

Law reform

Australian Law Reform Commission — current inquiries

Checked 21 September 2026

Where it stands

The Commission’s current inquiries (human tissue laws, final report due 25 September 2026; surrogacy laws, final report due 11 September 2026) do not carry a criminal justice remit. The most recent news item is the July 2026 In Brief. Monitored for new references.

Source →

About this issue

Compiled from 14 peer-reviewed journals and 11 government and law-reform sources. Retrieval and summarising are automated; Threshold Research Group checks each issue before publication but does not read every item in full. Each issue is a dated record and is not updated after publication.

How this issue was compiled — sources, scope and method

Journals: Criminology; Criminology & Public Policy; Journal of Criminal Justice; Journal of Experimental Criminology; Journal of Quantitative Criminology; Journal of Developmental and Life-Course Criminology; Justice Quarterly; Crime & Delinquency; British Journal of Criminology; Criminal Justice and Behavior; Sexual Abuse; Journal of Sexual Aggression; Trauma, Violence, & Abuse; Campbell Systematic Reviews.

Reports and legislation: Australian Institute of Criminology; NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research; ANROWS; Australian Institute of Health and Welfare; Queensland Audit Office; Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council; Productivity Commission; Queensland Parliament and the Queensland Legislation register; Queensland Law Reform Commission; Australian Law Reform Commission; the Commonwealth Parliament.

Items are selected for relevance to Australian justice agencies, courts, corrections, youth justice, and community-sector services, and are summarised descriptively from the published abstract, report or bill text. Scope: adult and youth criminal justice, sexual violence, and domestic and family violence. Inclusion is not endorsement, and summaries are not legal advice. Retrieval and summarising are automated. Before publication, Threshold Research Group gives each issue a brief editorial check for relevance, source details and obvious errors; items are not individually read in full. Errors or omissions are therefore possible — if you intend to rely on an item, go to the original source. Corrections are welcome at info@thresholdresearchgroup.com.au.

Response

  1. […] 22 September 2026 — Domestic and family violence: the bill and the emergency-department evidence […]